Chrishell Stause’s Twitter account recently liked two tweets, fans think hint at what happened with her ex-husband Justin Hartley. The actress broke the news of her divorce to fans on Selling Sunset, but never revealed the reason behind the split.

Neither of these theories have been confirmed to be the reason why Stause’s and Hartley’s marriage ended, but it appears cheating may have been involved.

The first tweet is from a fan, putting what they think the story is together. The post from August 7 reads, “@justinhartley filmed a movie in Canada at the same time his new gf @SofiaPernas was filming the summer before they split. The timing seems like he probably cheated on @Chrishell7 and took a cowards way out to avoid spousal support and gaslight her.”

The second tweet is from Blind Gossip which provides a link to the “solved” divorce story. The website claims that Hartley was cheating but tried to blame or frame Stause as cheating by finding old messages from her ex. “That totally put her on the defensive,” the website writes. “She was so worried about trying to prove HER innocence that she couldn’t even go after him for HIS cheating … That is how it went for a while. Then he filed for divorce.”

A source close to Hartley told Us Weekly that the rumors were “absolutely false” and claimed he did not cheat as “he didn’t even start talking to Sofia until the spring of 2020” and filed for divorce in November of last year.

The source also said that while Stause was told of the filing over text, the couple’s marriage had been in a bad spot for a while so she shouldn’t have been surprised by the news.